Indiana Sports Betting – Best IN Sportsbooks & Betting Sites in September 2023

Indiana is a destination for both sports and sports betting. The state has a very strong presence in football and basketball at both the collegiate and professional levels, with a number of championships finding their way to the Hoosier state over the decades.

Indiana was very quick to pull the trigger on legalizing sports betting compared to other US states. Retail sports betting became legal in Indiana in September 2019 and online sports betting went live not long after.

What Are the Top Indiana Sports Betting Apps?

The top 5 Indiana sports betting apps are always up for debate but after much discussion and weighing the pro’s and cons the ATS.io Editors’ came up with the following:

1. Caesars Sportsbook App – Best Indiana sports betting welcome bonus
2. FanDuel Sportsbook App – Best Indiana betting app for props and parlays
3. BetRivers App – Best player rewards program
4. BetMGM App – Top sports betting site for Futures Bets
5. DraftKings Sportsbook App – Combines the best of both worlds daily fantasy sports and sports betting

List of the Best Indiana Sports Betting Apps

The list of the best online sports betting apps in Indiana includes prominent names such as DraftKings Sportsbook, BetMGM, and FanDuel Online Sportsbook. Each of these Indiana sports betting sites has something to offer sports bettors, and many offer extra incentives to join through hefty sportsbook bonuses. Here are the best online sportsbook apps to choose from in Indiana:

1. Caesars Sportsbook

• Tech partner: William Hill
• Casino partner: Tropicana Evansville, Horseshoe Casino Hammond

Similar MGM Resorts, Caesars Entertainment is the company behind a number of Las Vegas’ biggest casinos and multiple chain casino brands including Horseshoe Casinos. Caesars had an established presence in Indiana through the Horseshoe Casino in Hammond, which gave a strong foothold for Caesars Sportsbook.

The Caesars Sportsbook App brings together two major gaming brands in Caesars and William Hill. This makes for a comprehensive sports betting experience either online or at retail. On top of that is its rewards program, which is tied to other Caesars-operated casinos. For those who regularly frequent Caesars’ casinos, this is a natural fit.

2. FanDuel Sportsbook

• Tech partner: FanDuel
• Casino partner: Blue Chip Casino, Belterra Casino Resort

The FanDuel sports betting app was among the first online options for sports bettors in Indiana. The daily fantasy sports site expanded into the realm of traditional sports betting and has become one of the biggest in the United States so far.

Indiana sports bettors have access to some great welcome bonuses from the site, which can be found below. FanDuel has a broad variety of banking options and a very good app, making it one of the most accessible online sportsbooks for new users. For regulars, it has a solid weekly promo game alongside Same Game Parlay Plus, a unique same game parlay system.

3. BetRivers

• Tech partner: Kambi
• Casino partner: French Lick Casino

The Rivers Casino chain exploded into the sports betting scene with BetRivers. The online sportsbook enjoys a retail presence in Indiana through the French Lick Casino, part of the French Lick Resort.

BetRivers is tailor-made for regular bettors thanks to its strong loyalty program and great bonus options. Standard 1x wagering on bonuses means that users can make the most out of its promotions. Now is also a great time to start with BetRivers, thanks to its strong welcome bonus:

4. BetMGM Sportsbook

• Tech partner: Entain
• Casino partner: Belterra Casino Resort

MGM Resorts is a familiar name for anyone that is interested in gambling in the United States. The company is behind some of the biggest casinos in Las Vegas, and operates a slew of other locations across the country. It’s also a force in sports betting through its BetMGM Sportsbook. 

BetMGM Sportsbook is available in Indiana, and it has a lot to offer. It has a very large selection of prop bets and weekly promos to keep things fun year-round. Make sure to check out our exclusive welcome bonus here:

5. DraftKings Sportsbook

• Tech partner: DraftKings
• Casino partner: Ameristar East Chicago

DraftKings has become one of the biggest brands in American sports, with the DraftKings Sportsbook being behind a slew of splashy partnerships. That includes the Indiana Pacers, with the sportsbook being the official betting and fantasy sports partner of the NBA franchise.

The name of the game with DraftKings Sportsbook is promos. DraftKings Sportsbook throws out regular promos for sports fans of any kind, not just welcome bonuses. That said, newcomers to DraftKings Sportsbook can also find something worth getting excited about in this department.

6. PointsBet

• Tech partner: PointsBet
• Casino partner: Hollywood Casino Lawrenceberg

PointsBet is a very good option for any Indiana sports bettors looking to focus on the Indianapolis Colts and the rest of the NFL. The sportsbook has very good lines for football and promotions for NFL games.

On top of that is Points Betting, PointsBet’s unique betting style. Points Betting is a twist on over/under betting that scales on how far over or under the final stats are. For example, if you bet on the Indianapolis Colts scoring over 20.5 points in a particular game, you will win more if they score 40 points than if they score 30. On the other hand, you’ll lose more if they get shut out than you would if they scored 15 points.

7. Unibet

• Tech partner: Kambi
• Casino partner: Horseshoe Casino Hammond

Unibet has been a staple of the European sports betting world for some time now and it’s getting legs in the United States as well. Its partnership with the Horseshoe Casino in Hammond allows it to offer action to Indiana sports bettors.

There are solid options for both new and veteran sports bettors when it comes to Unibet. A strong new user bonus can be found below, but the fun doesn’t end there. Once you get comfortable with sports betting, Unibet has tiered parlay boosts that offer bigger bonuses as you add more bets to your parlay. This is all on top of a great weekly promo offering.

8. WynnBet

• Tech partner: WynnBet
• Full sportsbook review: WynnBet 

WynnBet is another online sportsbook attached to a larger entertainment company. The bookmaker is an offshoot of the Wynn Resorts company, which runs a number of casinos around the world.

WynnBet runs a rewards program that is tied to the rewards promos used by its casinos. Beyond that, the sportsbook has a good welcome bonus, weekly promos, and an intuitive interface. WynnBet brings the glamour and elegance you can expect from the Wynn name from their retail casino to their online sportsbook and casino.

9. Barstool Sportsbook

• Tech partner: Kambi
• Casino partner: Hollywood Casino Lawrenceberg

Popular sports blog Barstool Sports is partly owned by Penn Entertainment, a casino and race track operator that runs the Hollywood Casino and Ameristar Casino brands. This has allowed Barstool Sportsbook to become established across the United States, including in Indiana.

The sportsbook throws loads of odds boosts, promos, and other bonuses to go along with its welcome bonus for new users. The real selling point is its integration with the Barstool Sports itself, putting the site’s personalities front-and-center.

Is Online Sports Betting Legal in Indiana?

Yes! Sports betting became legal in Indiana as of September 2019 with online sports betting going live in October 2019. The legalization process began from there and moved quickly relative to many other states. The official start date for sports betting in Indiana was September 1, 2019 with both retail and online sportsbooks coming out from there.

Where Can You Bet on Sports in Indiana?

Sports betting in Indiana went live in September 2019 now there are more than a dozen retail sports betting sites dotted across the state where players can bet on sports. Here are some of the best Indiana Casinos and locations to choose from and which online sportsbooks power them:

FanDuel Sportsbook at Belterra Casino Resort

• Location: 777 Belterra Dr, Florence, IN 47020
• Retail Sportsbook: FanDuel Sportsbook
• Other Features: Slots, table games, poker, golf

Belterra Casino and Resort is home to a FanDuel Sportsbook retail location, which gives gamers the chance to take in some sports when they’re not at the tables. The casino resort has a 47,000-square-foot gaming floor with over 1,000 terminals, 45 table games and two poker tables.

For those wanting to make a trip out of their visit to Florence, the casino has an adjoining hotel. Among the amenities is an 18-hole golf course with stay-and-play booking.

BetRivers at French Lick Resort Casino

• Location: 8670 West State Road 56, French Lick, IN 47432
• Retail Sportsbook: BetRivers
• Other Features: Slots, table games, golf

That combination of golf, casino, and sportsbook isn’t exclusive to the Belterra Casino Resort. The French Lick Resort Casino has all that with 45 holes across multiple courses and locations.

The sportsbook on location is operated by BetRivers. French Lick Resort Casino has a full lounge with a number of terminals for placing bets, as well as a bar. This allows bettors to sit down and watch the action unfold while having a drink.

Caesars Sportsbook at Caesars, Harrah’s Horseshoe Casino, and Winner’s Circle

• Winner’s Circle Location: 4300 N Michigan Rd, Shelbyville, IN 46176
• Winner’s Circle Location: 650 Eastern Blvd, Clarksville, IN 47129
• Winner’s Circle Location: 1304 Minnich Rd, New Haven, IN 46774
• Harrah’s Hoosier Park Location: 4500 Dan Patch Cir, Anderson, IN 46013
• Horseshoe Hammond Location: 777 Casino Center Dr, Hammond, IN 46320
• Caesars Southern Indiana Location: 11999 Casino Center Dr SE, Elizabeth, IN 47117
• Retail Sportsbook: Caesars Sportsbook
• Other Features: Slots, table games, racing

Caesars Sportsbook has a slew of retail sports betting sites located in Indiana. The company runs a number of casinos and race tracks across the state, with each one having a Caesars Sportsbook on hand to take bets.

Each location has something to offer. Winner’s Circle offers off-track betting, Horseshoe and Caesars have the full trimmings of a casino, while Harrah’s has both. Caesars Entertainment has something for everyone in Indiana.

William Hill at Bally’s Evansville

• Location: 421 NW Riverside Dr, Evansville, IN 47708
• Retail Sportsbook: William Hill
• Other Features: Slots, table games

Tropicana Evansville has been rebranded as Bally’s Evansville, but it still has exactly what you’d expect. The 45,000-square-foot gaming floor has over 1,000 slot machines and 30 table games, with restaurants and events to enjoy outside gaming.

It also has a William Hill sportsbook on hand for those looking to take in a game. Having a William Hill sportsbook is notable, as William Hill Indiana was folded into Caesars Sportsbook after the two sides committed to their partnership. That makes this sportsbook a unique one that is worth checking out if you happen to be visiting Evansville. 

Barstool Sportsbook at Hollywood Casino, Ameristar Casino Resort

• Ameristar Casino Resort Location: 777 Aldis Ave, East Chicago, IN 46312
• Hollywood Casino Location: 777 Hollywood Blvd, Lawrenceburg, IN 47025
• Retail Sportsbook: Barstool Sportsbook
• Other Features: Slots, table games, poker

Barstool Sports is partly owned by Penn Entertainment, which runs casinos across the United States. That sees Barstool Sportsbook retail locations at the Hollywood Casino and Ameristar Casino Resort.

The Ameristar Casino Resort has 56,000 square feet of gaming space across four floors, with slots, table games, and a dedicated 19-table baccarat room. The Hollywood Casino in Lawrenceburg has a huge 150,000-square-foot gaming space with 1,300 slot machines, 70 tables, a poker room, and more.

Alongside these are a number of other retail Indiana sports betting sites that can be found in the Hoosier state. Here is a full list:

How To Get Started Sports Betting In Indiana

What Sports Can I Bet on in Indiana?

Sports bettors in Indiana can bet on basically any sport they want. This encompasses both amateur and professional events, meaning sports bettors can enjoy betting on both NCAA and top sports leagues. The one big asterisk is that bettors cannot place prop bets on collegiate events, as only moneyline bets on a game’s outcome are allowed.

Here are some of the sports that can be bet on in Indiana:

• NFL
• NBA
• NCAA Football
• NCAA Basketball
• NHL
• MMA
• Boxing
• MLB
• Esports
• Tennis
• Soccer
• PGA
• Racing
• Darts
• Lacrosse

Available Bet Types in Indiana

Moneyline

Moneyline betting is probably what comes to mind when you think about sports betting. These bets are just direct bets on the outcome of a match, picking one side to beat the other.

Spread

Betting with a spread, called a handicap in some regions, makes for a much different experience. Though you’re still betting based on which team will win a game, “the spread” makes it so the pre-game favorite needs to win by a certain number of points. This can result in better lines, but keeps things tense until the final bell sounds.

Live betting

Tip-off doesn’t mean that the betting windows close. Live betting lets you place wagers on a game that’s currently underway. The betting lines shift as the action unfolds, which allows you to pick the perfect time to bet on a comeback.

Over/Unders

Betting on over/unders allows you to wager on how many points a team will score during a contest. For example, a line might be offered on the Indianapolis Colts scoring over or under 20.5 points during a game. If the Colts score 21 points or more the over wins, while 20 or fewer is a win for an under bet.

Totals

Do you have two of your favorite teams playing against each other, you want to bet on the game, but you just don’t want to have to root against one of them? Totals lets you do that by picking an over/under on the total points scored by both teams combined.

Prop bets

Prop bets look at facets of a contest beyond just the winner or the points scored. Who will score the first touchdown? Will a point be deducted from a fighter during an MMA match? Will a baseball game go to extra innings? That’s just a tiny taste of common prop markets.

Parlays

Parlays are a batch of bets placed together. Instead of placing a series of bets, parlays allow you to wager that all of these bets will land. This boosts the potential winnings with each bet that is added, but each prediction needs to be correct in order to have the parlay pay off.

Teams to Bet on in Indiana

Indianapolis Colts

The Indianapolis Colts have been the favorite team of Indiana sports fans for some time now. The NFL franchise was dominant in the 2000s and 2010s in large part thanks to the Peyton Manning-led offense. The team’s consistency led many to put this era of the Colts above the legendary Don Shula and Johnny Unitas years in the 1960s.

The post-Manning years haven’t been as kind to the team, but the Colts aren’t helpless. The team has still found its way into the playoffs on multiple occasions in the years since.

Indiana Pacers

The Indiana Pacers don’t have NBA championships to their name, but the team has typically given fans in the state something to cheer for. The team’s deep playoff runs from 2011 to 2014 might feel like a distant memory, but the team has still made the postseason more often than not.

The team hit the skids in Rick Carlisle’s first season as head coach. The franchise is hoping that reboot will pay off in the long term.

Notre Dame Fighting Irish

Notre Dame University is one of the most recognizable names in collegiate sports. It fields more than 20 varsity teams and has enjoyed success in almost all of them, something that has made the school a rival for other colleges across the country.

For sports betting purposes, Notre Dame’s most relevant teams are its basketball teams. Both its men’s and women’s teams are competitive at a national level, and are more likely to appear during the NCAA Tournament than not. Though it hasn’t enjoyed quite the same success in recent years, the Fighting Irish football team remains relevant due to its enduring rivalries and regular appearances in bowl games.

Indiana Hoosiers

The Indiana University Bloomington has more than 20 varsity teams and flexes its muscles in a number of sports. The team is a rival to many other Indiana collegiate sports teams, something borne from over 100 years of competition in the Big Ten conference.

Indiana has a slew of teams that are credible at the national level but the most successful is likely its women’s basketball team. The Hoosiers’ women’s basketball team has made deep runs in multiple NCAA Tournaments, including an Elite Eight berth in 2021 and a Sweet Sixteen finish in 2022. That said its men’s basketball team and football team are still of interest for sports bettors.

Purdue Boilermakers

Purdue University fields a number of strong teams in the Big Ten conference, but the Boilermakers are best known for the men’s basketball team. The team has made multiple deep runs into the NCAA Tournament in recent years, making the Elite Eight in 2019 and Sweet Sixteen in 2022.

While men’s basketball is the highlight for Purdue athletics, Boilermakers football is on a serious upswing as well. After finishing under .500 in 11 of 13 seasons between 2007 and 2020, Purdue football rebounded with a very good 2021 season and is poised to be a force in the coming seasons.

Butler Bulldogs

While Purdue, Notre Dame, and Indiana all mix things up, Butler is basically separate from all that. The school primarily competes in the Big East conference instead of Big Ten and in the Pioneer Football League in football, keeping it largely separate from other Indiana collegiate teams.

The school lorded over all in men’s basketball in the early 2010s, making NCAA Tournament finals appearances in 2010 and 2011 and popping up in the tournament each year from 2015 to 2018. Butler hasn’t been able to find that degree of success in recent seasons but the school could bounce back in the future.

Indiana has several other NCAA Division I program schools and several other pro teams that call the state their home. Here are some of the most notable:

• Indiana Fever
• Indy Eleven
• FC Indiana
• South Bend Cubs
• Fort Wayne TinCaps
• Ball State Cardinals
• Butler Bulldogs
• Indiana State Sycamores
• Valparaiso Beacons

History of Indiana Sports Betting

As with most states, Indiana has a long history of sports betting but was subject to the nationwide sports betting ban that was passed in 1992 with the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act. This was overturned by the United States Supreme Court in 2018, which gave states the opportunity to individually decide whether sports betting should be legal within their borders.

Indiana was relatively quick to take advantage of this. In May 2019, IN HB1015 passed with bipartisan support and was signed into law by the governor. The bill legalized sports betting in the state, outlined the licensing process, and provided taxation guidelines.

Licenses were administered and the first bets were accepted on September 1 at select casinos in the state. The following October saw mobile sportsbook open, allowing bettors to wager from the comfort of their own home.

Indiana Sports Betting FAQ