Dark horses of the NHL in the Stanley Cup Playoffs : Where the value begins after the favorites
Updated March 19, 2026
Updated March 19, 2026
The Stanley Cup futures board always starts with the obvious names. Right now, Colorado sits near the top at around +240 to +330, with Tampa Bay close behind at roughly +350 to +370 and Carolina in the next cluster at about +450 to +600. Those are the teams the market trusts most: elite talent, balanced rosters, and the kind of profile that usually survives four playoff rounds.
But this is the NHL. The postseason has a habit of flattening the gap between heavyweight and outsider, and that is where the dark-horse conversation gets interesting. The trick is not just finding a team that can win a round. It is finding one whose number still leaves room for real value if things break right.
Colorado Avalanche (+280 to +330): The market’s preferred choice for good reason. Colorado has the star power, the speed and the top-end ceiling that can overwhelm teams in a seven-game series.
Tampa Bay Lightning (+350 to +370): Even if there are fresher teams in the conversation, Tampa Bay still carries the look of a spring team. Experience matters in this tournament, and few clubs can match theirs.
Carolina Hurricanes (+450 to +550): Carolina remains one of the safest all-around bets on the board. Structure, depth and consistency make the Hurricanes easy to trust, even if the price is no longer generous.
And as always, you can't talk about favorites to win the Stanley Cup without mentioning the President's Trophy Curse.
Minnesota Wild (+1700 to +1800): This is the classic “second shelf” futures ticket. The Wild are outsiders because they do not have the same market shine as Colorado or Tampa Bay, and their path in the West could be brutal. But that is exactly why the number is interesting. They are good enough to contend, yet still priced like a step below the elite.
Buffalo Sabres (+2200 to +2400): Buffalo is no longer a feel-good surprise. At this price, the Sabres are a live dark horse. They are still discounted because the franchise lacks recent playoff credibility, but futures value often lives in teams the market is late to fully trust. If their speed and confidence translate into playoff hockey, this is one of the better numbers on the board.
Pittsburgh Penguins (+5000 to +6000): The Pittsburgh Penguins’ case as a dark horse rests almost entirely on elite playoff experience at the top of the roster. Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Kris Letang have each played in four Stanley Cup Finals (2008, 2009, 2016, 2017), winning three championships together and forming one of the most battle-tested cores of the modern era. Bryan Rust also brings Finals pedigree, having played a key role in the 2016 and 2017 Cup wins. Add to that Stuart Skinner who played in the finals with the Oilers for the past two seasons (although he is not the number one goalie at the moment). While the Penguins lack the depth and consistency of true contenders, few teams can match this level of championship experience. If Pittsburgh reaches the postseason, that core alone gives them a level of composure and know-how that makes them far more dangerous than their long odds suggest.
As the Penguins handled the Crosby-Malkin absence in February and March quite well, this is my favorite dark horse. Is it unlikely? Yes. But there's a lot of Stanley Cup experience in this core squad, including the goalie Stuart Skinner who played in the final with the Oilers for the past two seasons (however, he's not currently the number one goalie for Pittsburgh)
Boston Bruins (+10000 to +15000): Boston is not a trendy sleeper. Boston is a pure price play. The market has largely written off the Bruins, which is why the number is so large. That makes them risky, but it also makes them interesting. In the playoffs, defensive structure and goaltending can drag a team much further than expected. Boston is an outsider because its overall ceiling looks lower than the contenders’, but at this kind of price, the question is not whether they are likely champions. It is whether they are more live than the number implies.
They've been terrible on the road, but fantastic at home (they had a 13-game winning streak at TD Garden stretching from January to March). This could prove to be pivotal if they reach the playoffs.
If you want the cleanest path, start with Colorado, Tampa Bay or Carolina. If you want value, the conversation shifts quickly to Minnesota and Buffalo. If you want true longshot upside, Pittsburgh and Boston are the names that stand out, not because they are safe, but because their odds finally reflect real doubt.
That is the dark-horse sweet spot in the Stanley Cup market: teams flawed enough to be discounted, but dangerous enough to make those prices matter.
Affiliate DisclosureATS.io uses affiliate links. If you sign up through a link on this page, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Rankings are based on hands-on testing and published criteria, and affiliate relationships do not determine placement.
