New York Yankees vs Toronto Blue Jays Pick – 7/1/2025
This Tuesday at 3:07 p.m. ET, the New York Yankees (48‑36) visit the Toronto Blue Jays (46‑38) at Rogers Centre. After the Blue Jays won Monday’s opener 5‑4, this is a crucial Canada Day showdown. DraftKings lists NYY as the favorite, with the low total suggesting a pitching duel. Here, I make my Yankees vs Blue Jays prediction for Tuesday afternoon. Pick: New York Yankees moneyline Confidence: ★★★★☆ Score Projection: Yankees 5 – Blue Jays 3 Win Probability: Yankees 55 %, Blue Jays 45 % Max Fried is the best pitcher on the field this afternoon, and while Toronto’s bullpen has held firm recently, the weakened Yankees’ middle relief looks likely to preserve a Fried‑led lead. The Blue Jays’ batters have struggled vs southpaws, with a sub‑.235 average. Given the ace’s dominance, strong runline record, and consistent road form, backing the Yankees straight up offers value. Expect low to moderate scoring, but enough offense for New York to hold serve.Our Yankees vs Blue Jays Pick
Game Snapshot
Odds Moneyline Total Yankees ‑167 8 Blue Jays +139 Key Storylines
Pitching form
Bullpen usage
Recent team streaks
Best Player Props
Player Prop Line Aaron Judge (NYY) Home runs Over 0.5 Max Fried (NYY) Strikeouts Over 5.5 K Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (TOR) Total bases Under 1.5 Betting Trends & H2H
Yankees vs Blue Jays Model Projection
Final Thoughts