Heisman Trophy Odds & Predictions: Favorites to Win the Heisman

Updated October 29, 2026


Updated October 29, 2026

The 2026 Heisman Trophy race is shaping up to be one of the most intriguing in recent years, with standout wide receivers challenging the quarterbacks who traditionally dominate college football's most prestigious individual award. Ohio State's Jeremiah Smith, Miami's Darian Mensah and Malachi Toney, and several other contenders have positioned themselves in the conversation. As the regular season approaches its conclusion, several key factors could dramatically reshape the Heisman Trophy futures odds before voting begins in December.
The explosive receiver has delivered a historic season, although a QB injury creates uncertainty for him.
His passing efficiency and his leadership of Miami's offense make him the strongest QB.
A breakout performance against Pitt has elevated the dynamic WR into consideration.
The talented QB remains a contender but needs signature performances to strengthen his case.
The freshman sensation has produced extraordinary receiving numbers for Oregon State.
The explosive receiver has delivered a historic season, although a QB injury creates uncertainty for him.
His passing efficiency and his leadership of Miami's offense make him the strongest QB.
A breakout performance against Pitt has elevated the dynamic WR into consideration.
The talented QB remains a contender but needs signature performances to strengthen his case.
The freshman sensation has produced extraordinary receiving numbers for Oregon State.
Our prediction to win the 2026 Heisman Trophy is Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith. His combination of explosive production, consistency, and game-changing ability has made him one of the most compelling individual performers in college football. Although quarterbacks have historically dominated Heisman voting, Smith is putting together the type of exceptional receiving season that could overcome that positional preference.
The biggest concern surrounding Smith's candidacy and the fate of college football predictions backing him to win is the injury to Ohio State quarterback Julian Sayin, which could affect his opportunities in the passing game. However, Smith's ability to create explosive plays and deliver in high-profile matchups gives him a realistic path to the award even with a different quarterback. If he maintains his production through the final weeks of the regular season, his individual accomplishments should be difficult for voters to overlook.
Miami quarterback Darian Mensah represents Smith's biggest threat, particularly if the Hurricanes continue winning and Mensah delivers a memorable performance against Notre Dame. However, teammate Malachi Toney's emergence as a legitimate candidate could divide first-place support among Miami's stars. Smith remains our choice to take home the Heisman, provided Ohio State continues finding ways to showcase its most dynamic offensive weapon.
Positional History
Quarterbacks have dominated recent Heisman voting, while wide receivers have won the award just four times.
Heisman Moments
Memorable performances in nationally televised games can significantly influence voters and reshape the award narrative.
Teammate Competition
Multiple candidates from the same team can compete for first-place votes, potentially benefiting contenders from other programs.
Production & Opportunity
Evaluate whether a player's role, supporting personnel, and remaining schedule provide enough opportunities to build an award-winning statistical résumé.