Italy vs France Prediction: Predicted Lineups & Tactical Breakdown

Updated November 12, 2026
Italy vs France Match Preview
.webp%3F2026-11-12T09%253A24%253A15.019Z&w=3840&q=75&dpl=34f4233406f9feaee4739285db0396a5c5dd7196)

Updated November 12, 2026
.webp%3F2026-11-12T09%253A24%253A15.019Z&w=3840&q=75&dpl=34f4233406f9feaee4739285db0396a5c5dd7196)
A draw at San Siro tonight sends France into the Nations League quarter-finals, and a win would seal top spot in Group A1. They’ll have to get it without Kylian Mbappé, who Zinedine Zidane ruled out on Wednesday, or Ousmane Dembélé and Aurélien Tchouaméni.
Italy took a point in Paris in October and created the better chances that night, even if Donnarumma ultimately preserved their point with some late heroics. Kalshi has France at 49¢, Italy at 27¢ and the draw at 25¢. The ATS Quantitative Model points towards Italy for this matchup, but the market has already caught up with France's absences, leaving little edge in the market.
France are short of their best players
France may have arguably the deepest squad in Europe, but even they may struggle to overcome this injury crisis. Mbappé, Dembélé, Tchouaméni, Marcus Thuram, William Saliba, Jules Koundé, Pierre Kalulu and Manu Koné are all out. Without Tchouaméni, France have no natural holding midfielder, so Rayan Cherki, Lucas Da Cunha and Adrien Rabiot are likely to start in midfield again, as they did in Paris. Désiré Doué is expected to lead the line as a false nine.
Italy have the blueprint for success vs France
France had 65% of the ball and 50 touches in the Italian box in October, but they only created one big chance and 1.17 xG. Italy had 35% possession and produced 1.55 xG and three big chances. While Gianluigi Donnarumma made seven saves, these were mostly from low quality chances as France struggled to break down the Italian low block. Expect Mancini to employ a similar approach to stifle France's creativity in Milan tonight.
The ATS Quantitative Model and the market agree
The ATS Quantitative Model makes France 46%, the draw 26% and Italy 28%, close to Polymarket’s 48¢, 27¢ and 27¢. That puts Italy or the draw at 52%, leaving little edge on the table for potential traders.
Recommended Position:
No positionLean:
Italy +0.5
Current Price:
52¢
Model Probability:
54%
Market Probability:
52%
Model Edge:
2%
Entry Threshold:
50¢
Model Confidence:
48/100Why I'm passing on this market

“This isn't the same France side that sparkled at the World Cup. With a huge list of absentees and clear gaps within the squad, France go to Milan with an experimental side particularly lacking at the back and in midfield. Italy held a star-studded France XI in Paris last month, and I'm backing them to do the same here. However, the market has already reacted to France's absences, leaving no edge on the table according to our model. If France No were to fall to 50 cents I would be tempted to make a small trade, but I'm passing for now.”
Nations League group stage, four matches each. Per game unless marked as a total.
Metric | Italy | France |
|---|---|---|
xG | 1.88 | 1.38 |
xGA | 2.11 | 1.01 |
Goals / xG (total) | 8 / 7.51 | 7 / 5.51 |
Goals conceded / xGA (total) | 5 / 8.43 | 2 / 4.04 |
Possession | 45.5% | 65.0% |
Shots | 16.0 | 17.8 |
Shots conceded | 16.5 | 10.8 |
Touches in opposition box | 25.3 | 48.0 |
Big chances created / conceded (total) | 15 / 13 | 9 / 8 |
France control games but create little. They average almost twice as many touches in the box as Italy, yet they’ve made only nine big chances in four games to Italy’s 15.
Italy are open at both ends. They create more than France but also concede 2.11 xG and 16.5 shots per game. Gianluigi Donnarumma’s saves are the main reason they’ve let in only five goals from 8.43 xGA.
France’s finishing has carried them. They’ve scored 1.5 more goals than their xG, and five of their seven have come after the 75th minute.
October’s meeting followed the same pattern. France had 65% of the ball in Paris, but Italy out-created them 1.55 xG to 1.17.
Key players, Nations League group stage
Player | Mins | Goals / xG | Assists / xA | Shots (on target) | Chances created | Box touches |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Michael Olise (FRA) | 211 | 4 / 1.08 | 2 / 0.92 | 10 (7) | 7 | 19 |
Désiré Doué (FRA) | 215 | 1 / 0.44 | 2 / 1.00 | 11 (5) | 6 | 25 |
Rayan Cherki (FRA) | 197 | 1 / 0.63 | 2 / 0.59 | 4 (2) | 7 | 19 |
Lucas Da Cunha (FRA) | 205 | 0 / 0.01 | 1 / 0.26 | 1 (0) | 5 | 0 |
Francesco Pio Esposito (ITA) | 236 | 2 / 1.29 | 1 / 0.38 | 6 (5) | 5 | 22 |
Alessandro Bastoni (ITA) | 270 | 2 / 0.43 | 0 / 0.04 | 5 (2) | 1 | 5 |
Davide Frattesi (ITA) | 193 | 1 / 1.14 | 0 / 0.20 | 5 (1) | 3 | 5 |
Sandro Tonali (ITA) | 262 | 0 / 0.23 | 0 / 0.09 | 5 (0) | 1 | 3 |
Olise has scored four goals from just 1.08 xG. His shots on target were worth 2.07 xGOT, so he’s placing them well, but scoring nearly double that is a rate few players sustain.
Doué is France’s most creative player. He leads them in xA (1.00), touches in the box (25) and successful dribbles (8 of 15), and he’s also made nine tackles. He’s expected to play as the false nine tonight.
Da Cunha doesn’t get into the box, but he moves the ball. He’s completed 192 of his 204 passes and made 22 passes into the final third, the most of any player in the table.
Pio Esposito is Italy’s focal point. Five of his six shots have been on target, he has 22 touches in the box, and he’s won half of his aerial duels.
Bastoni has two goals from only 0.43 xG. He’s also completed 91% of his passes and made 12 passes into the final third from centre-back.
Tonali rarely shoots or creates, but he’s the player who starts Italy’s breaks. He’s completed 138 of 151 passes and leads the Italian midfield with 15 recoveries.
The first meeting set the pattern. France had the ball, circulated it patiently and struggled to break down an Italian side happy to defend deep and break. Expect the same tonight, except this time France are without the two players most likely to unlock a low block, Mbappé and Dembélé.
That puts more on Olise. He'll start on the right and cut inside onto his left foot, and Calafiori's job is to stop him getting there. Doué will drop off from the false nine role to link with Cherki, which leaves France short of a penalty-box presence. Bradley Barcola's pace on the left is their main threat in behind.
Italy's chances will come in transition. Without Tchouaméni, France's midfield three of Cherki, Da Cunha and Rabiot doesn't have a natural screen, and Nicolò Barella and Davide Frattesi will run beyond Pio Esposito whenever Italy win the ball. Sandro Tonali is the player who starts those breaks.
Set pieces could decide it. Bastoni, Giorgio Scalvini and Pio Esposito are all aerial threats, and both Calafiori and Pio Esposito have scored headers in this campaign. France will be without Saliba and Koundé, and Upamecano is only just back from suspension.
The danger for Italy is the last 20 minutes. France have scored five of their seven goals after the 75th minute, and Italy have conceded in every group game. If it's level late on, Zidane's bench is where France will look.
Expected starting XIs · Both teams attack upwards
Predicted lineups, not confirmed team sheets. Check the latest team news before kickoff.