Arsenal vs Everton Player Props: Guimarães & Barry Lead the Way

Updated October 23, 2026


Updated October 23, 2026

Arsenal welcome Everton to the Emirates on Saturday unbeaten in their last seven meetings, and the Toffees have won just once in their last 30 trips to face the Gunners.
Arsenal have allowed just 6.3 xG in seven league games, the fewest in the Premier League, and only 1.4 xG across three home fixtures. They'll be without Bukayo Saka after his quad injury in Munich, though, and his 24 shots and 11 shots on target this season need a new home. That pushes volume toward Bruno Guimarães (+150) and Martin Ødegaard (+145).
Everton arrive unbeaten on the road, with three draws from three away league games, and Thierno Barry (+120) has taken three or more shots in seven of his last 10 appearances. Below are the model probabilities, buy-up prices, and trigger points for our Arsenal vs Everton props, headlined by a +14.0% edge on Guimarães.
The projection clears the price
The ATS Quantitative Model projects 0.71 shots on target for Guimarães against Everton, which works out to about a 51% chance of at least one. BetMGM's +150 only asks you to believe 40%.
Bruno's volume is historically high
He's put a shot on target in six of his last 10 appearances, including both home outings, and had five shots against Lille. Last season at Newcastle he landed 23 on target in 2,459 league minutes, and with Everton likely to sit in a low block.
Saka's shots need a new owner
Arsenal average 7.67 shots on target at home, and Saka was putting 1.22 per game on target. Against a deep Everton block, more of that volume falls to midfielders arriving from range.
Recommended Prediction:
Guimarães Over 0.5 Shots on Target
Current Market Price:
+150 (40¢)
Model Probability:
51%
Market-Implied Probability:
40%
Model Edge:
+11%
Buy Up To:
45¢
Model Confidence:
61/100
Everton's only real shot engine
Barry has 25 shots and 11 on target in seven league games, 3.6 shots a game. He's cleared three shots in seven of his last 10 appearances and four of his last five away from home.
Arsenal concede attempts, not chances
Arsenal allow just 3.0 shots on target a game, the fewest in the league, but opponents still get close to 10 attempts. This line counts every attempt, blocked and off target included, and Barry takes about a quarter of Everton's.
Game state helps
Arsenal are heavy favorites, so Everton should spend the closing stretch chasing. That's when a lone striker's shot count climbs. I have him at 50% to reach three, against 45.5% implied at +120.
Recommended Prediction:
Thierno Barry Over 2.5 Shots
Current Market Price:
+120 (46¢)
Model Probability:
50%
Market-Implied Probability:
45.5%
Model Edge:
+4.5%
Buy Up To:
+100 (50¢)
Model Confidence:
54/100Manchester City
Aston Villa
| Sportsbook | AV | MNC |
|---|---|---|
| Kalshi | +1.5 64.0¢ | -1.5 37.0¢ |
| Polymarket | +1.5 65.0¢ | -1.5 37.0¢ |
| Sportsbook | over | under |
|---|---|---|
| Kalshi | 3.5 42.0¢ | 3.5 59.0¢ |
| Polymarket | 3.5 41.0¢ | 3.5 60.0¢ |
| FanDuel | 1.5 -700 | 5.5 -1300 |
| BetMGM | 3.5 +125 | 3.5 -175 |
| BetRivers | 3.5 +125 | 3.5 -162 |
| Sportsbook | AV | MNC | Draw |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kalshi | 19.0¢ | 60.9¢ | 23.0¢ |
| Polymarket | 19.0¢ | 60.9¢ | 22.0¢ |
| FanDuel | +390 | -165 | +350 |
| Fanatics | +400 | -160 | +330 |
| BetMGM | +350 | -145 | +320 |
| BetRivers | +400 | -167 | +350 |
| DraftKings | +380 | -155 | +340 |