Switzerland vs Scotland Prediction: Can Motivated Scots Upset the Swiss?

Updated November 16, 2026
Switzerland vs Scotland Match Preview


Updated November 16, 2026

Switzerland have secured promotion back to League A, so tonight in St. Gallen matters far more to Scotland. Sébastien Pocognoli's side need to win and hope Slovenia drop points in North Macedonia, which would take them into second place and a promotion play-off.
Switzerland beat Scotland 3-0 at Hampden in September, but the Scots were down to 10 men for 79 minutes that night, and can call upon Scott McTominay, Kieran Tierney and Ché Adams, all of whom missed out through injury in October.
Switzerland have nothing left to play for, and at 48¢, Switzerland No (Scotland to win or draw) is my position.
The hammering at Hampden needs context
Hendry saw red in the 11th minute at Hampden, and Ricardo Rodríguez scored the free kick a minute later. Scotland played almost 80 minutes with ten men, which is why Switzerland had 77% of the ball and 23 shots to two. Two of Switzerland's three goals that night came from corners. Since then, Scotland have beaten North Macedonia twice and lost 2-1 at home to Slovenia. Switzerland remain the class of the group, but they have little to play for tonight.
Scotland's finishing woes
Scotland have produced 11.07 xG and 19 big chances in five group games, yet they've scored only five goals. Kieron Bowie has missed five big chances on his own, and Oli McBurnie has three without scoring. McTominay, Tierney and Adams all missed October, and Friday's 2-1 win over North Macedonia was the first time Pocognoli has been able to start all three.
The ATS Quantitative Model leans towards Scotland
Polymarket lists a Swiss win at 53¢. The ATS Quantitative Model makes Switzerland 46.8%, the draw 27.7% and Scotland 25.4%. That puts Scotland or the draw at 53.2%, while Switzerland "No" costs 48¢. The model also expects fewer goals than the market, with under 2.5 at 55.8% against 49¢ on Polymarket.
Recommended Position:
Switzerland NO/ Scotland win or draw
Current Price:
48¢
Model Probability:
53.2%
Market Probability:
48%
Model Edge:
5.2%
Entry Threshold:
50¢
Model Confidence:
61/100
Score Prediction:
Switzerland 1-1 Scotland
Why I'm Going Against the form book

“Switzerland have been excellent in this group. Four clean sheets, one goal conceded, and not a single big chance given away in five games. But they're promoted, Manzambi has gone home, and this is a dead rubber for them. Scotland need the win, and McTominay, Tierney and Adams give them a much stronger team than the one that played most of September's game with ten men. I don't expect a lot of goals. A 1-1 feels right, and Scotland or the draw at 48¢ is good value.”
Nations League group stage, five matches each. Per game unless marked as a total.
Metric | Switzerland | Scotland |
|---|---|---|
xG | 1.46 | 2.21 |
xGA | 0.24 | 0.76 |
Goals / xG (total) | 11 / 7.28 | 5 / 11.07 |
Goals conceded / xGA (total) | 1 / 1.19 | 6 / 3.80 |
Possession | 66.2% | 48.0% |
Shots | 18.4 | 14.8 |
Shots conceded | 5.0 | 10.6 |
Touches in opposition box | 28.0 | 25.0 |
Big chances created / conceded (total) | 10 / 0 | 19 / 7 |
Switzerland's defence has been remarkable. They've allowed five shots on target and no big chances in five games, and the only goal they've conceded came in the second minute against Slovenia.
Switzerland have scored 3.72 more goals than their xG. Four of their 11 came from set pieces, including two corners and a free kick against Scotland.
Scotland's xG is lifted by the two North Macedonia games, which gave them 6.68 of their 11.07. They've still scored six fewer goals than their chances deserved.
Switzerland play a 4-2-3-1 built on control. Manuel Akanji has completed 473 of 512 passes and made 75 passes into the final third, and Freuler and Denis Zakaria sit in front of him. Switzerland average 66.2% possession and allow only five shots a game.
Their attack goes through the right. Ndoye's 49 touches in the box are more than any two of his teammates combined, and Fabian Rieder drifts inside from the 10 to support him. Embolo leads the line, but he played only 59 minutes against Slovenia on Friday.
Scotland’s 3-4-1-2 is built to deal with Switzerland’s main threat. Ndoye plays on the right, straight into Andy Robertson and Kieran Tierney, and with three centre-backs, Tierney can follow him when he cuts inside without leaving a gap in the middle. That means Robertson isn’t left one-on-one. Expect Scotland to drop into a back five for long spells. They’ve averaged 48% possession in the group, and Switzerland have had 66%.
The shape changes when Scotland win the ball. Billy Gilmour has made 18 line-breaking passes and 48 passes into the final third, and with McGinn playing behind two strikers, there’s always a runner for him to find. That’s what was missing in October, when Kieron Bowie and Oli McBurnie missed eight big chances between them.
With McTominay and Adams up front on Friday, Scotland had 18 shots, 3.23 xG and six big chances against North Macedonia, and both forwards had eight touches in the box. Switzerland have allowed only five shots a game, so Scotland won’t get that many chances in St. Gallen. But if Gilmour can find McGinn between the lines, they have more ways into the box than they did in September.
Set pieces could decide it. Switzerland have scored four of their 11 from dead balls. Scotland conceded twice from corners at Hampden in September, and again from a corner against North Macedonia on Friday. If Scotland keep it level and tight at the back, Switzerland have little reason to take risks late on.
Expected starting XIs · Both teams attack upwards
Predicted lineups, not confirmed team sheets. Check the latest team news before kickoff.