Oilers vs Panthers Prediction: Is Edmonton Being Undervalued?

Updated November 16, 2026


Updated November 16, 2026

The Florida Panthers have been a nightmare opponent for Edmonton, beating the Oilers in consecutive Stanley Cup Finals in 2024 and 2025. The stakes are considerably lower this time, but I suspect Connor McDavid and company haven't forgotten those defeats.
Edmonton arrives in Florida with five consecutive victories, a 16-3-3 record and an extraordinary 9-0-1 start on the road. McDavid has recorded a point in every game this season, while Leon Draisaitl is already at 20 goals.
Despite all that, the Panthers are slight favorites. I'm not convinced they should be.
Florida has the home-ice advantage, but there's very little separating these teams in the prediction markets.
Team | Kalshi YES | Polymarket US YES |
|---|---|---|
Edmonton Oilers | 46¢ | 48¢ |
Florida Panthers | 56¢ | 53¢ |
November 16 snapshots. Prices are from different observations and may change before puck drop.
It's difficult to find much wrong with Edmonton's recent performances.
The Oilers have won eight of their last 10 games, allowing just 1.6 goals per game during that stretch. Sunday's 5-2 victory over Philadelphia was another strong result, with Draisaitl scoring twice and McDavid collecting three points.
McDavid now has 53 points in 22 games, including 41 assists. His season-opening point streak has reached 22 games, putting him alongside some of the greatest starts in NHL history.
Draisaitl hasn't exactly been quiet either. He's scored 20 goals, including eight during his current nine-game point streak.
The Panthers know these players better than most teams, having faced them in two consecutive Stanley Cup Finals. But knowing how dangerous McDavid and Draisaitl are and actually stopping them remain two very different things.
The Panthers are 12-7-3 and have been particularly competitive at home. They're also coming off a narrow 2-1 overtime loss in Dallas, which ended a three-game winning streak.
Matthew Tkachuk scored Florida's only goal against the Stars, reaching 700 career points in the process. He's now riding an eight-game point streak, while Sam Reinhart and Carter Verhaeghe provide additional offensive quality.
The biggest concern is the continued absence of Aleksander Barkov and Brad Marchand.
Florida has managed reasonably well without them, but Barkov's defensive importance becomes particularly relevant against Edmonton. There are few centers better equipped to handle McDavid's combination of speed, creativity and puck possession.
Without its captain, Florida faces a difficult assignment against the NHL's most productive player.
Edmonton's goaltending has been considerably more dependable than expected this season.
Tristan Jarry made 34 saves against Philadelphia on Sunday, while Devon Levi has also impressed. With Jarry starting the previous game, Levi is a reasonable possibility against Florida, although neither goaltender has been confirmed.
The Panthers have a similar decision between Jacob Markstrom and Akira Schmid. Schmid made 20 saves in Sunday's overtime loss to Dallas, which could open the door for Markstrom.
Neither team has a confirmed starting goalie at the time of writing, so this is one area worth revisiting before the game.
Florida remains capable of shutting down dangerous opponents, but Edmonton's improved defensive performances give me more confidence in the visitors than their reputation from previous seasons might suggest.
Connor McDavid — 2+ Points YES
McDavid has collected 53 points in 22 games and hasn't been held off the scoresheet once this season. He had three points against Philadelphia, and Edmonton's offense continues to run through him. The 2+ points market is worth monitoring, particularly if the price offers something more attractive than his likely expensive 1+ point contract.
Matthew Tkachuk — 1+ Point YES
Tkachuk has recorded a point in eight consecutive games and remains Florida's most influential offensive player with Barkov unavailable. His 700th career point came against Dallas, and he'll be central to the Panthers' chances of slowing Edmonton's winning streak.
These are supporting markets to watch, not official priced selections.
No data available