Butler Bulldogs vs Seton Hall Pirates Prediction & Picks - 1/17/2026

The Butler Bulldogs will face the Seton Hall Pirates in a Big East matchup on Saturday afternoon. Butler enters this contest struggling, having dropped four consecutive games, while Seton Hall has carved out a 14-3 overall record and shown why it’s ranked inside the top 25. With the Pirates favored at home, I break down all the action and give you my Butler vs Seton Hall prediction before the action begins in Newark.

Our Butler vs Seton Hall Pick

Game Snapshot

• Matchup: Butler Bulldogs @ Seton Hall Pirates
• Date & Time: Saturday, January 17, 2026, 12:00 PM ET
• Venue: Prudential Center, Newark, New Jersey
• Broadcast: TNT

Key Storylines

• Seton Hall has established itself as one of the stronger squads in the Big East this season with a 14-3 record and a 4-2 conference record. The Pirates are 8-2 at home and rank highly defensively, allowing just under 63 points per game. Their ability to control the glass and limit opponents’ scoring opportunities makes them a difficult team to beat in Newark.
• Butler enters on a four-game losing streak, including a recent 89-75 loss to Xavier. The Bulldogs are just 1-5 in Big East play and have struggled to find consistency on both ends of the floor. Their rebounding and three-point shooting can be strengths, but those positives have not translated into enough wins. Butler has lost three straight games by double-digits and will try to end that streak with a win here.
• Michael Ajayi had a 22-point outing for Butler in the loss to Xavier, showing he can impact games offensively. For Seton Hall, their defensive identity and ability to control tempo have been cornerstones of their success. The Pirates are incredibly well-balanced this year, as they don't have a player averaging 12 points per game or more this season.

Betting Trends

• Butler is 9-8 against the spread going into Saturday's Big East action.
• Seton Hall enters this contest with an 11-6 record against the spread.
• The Bulldogs are 8-8-1 in the over/under market heading into this matchup.
• The under is 9-8 in games involving Seton Hall this year.

Butler vs Seton Hall Model Projection

Score Projection: Butler 68 – Seton Hall 76 ATS PRO

Win Probability: Butler 27%, Seton Hall 73% ATS PRO

Final Thoughts

My recommendation for this game is for Seton Hall to win the game and cover the spread. The Pirates are not one of the more explosive offensive teams in college basketball. But they are going to bludgeon their opponents with their defense and physicality night in and night out. They should wear down the Butler Bulldogs in this game and win by close to double-digits, covering the number as the Pirates rebound nicely from their loss to UConn last time out.

Jay Sanin

Jay Sanin is the GM and Head of Sports at ATS.io. He has been writing about sports gambling since 2013, handicapping tens of thousands of sporting events. He plays sides and totals aggressively across most sports and is more selective in player prop markets. He does his own modeling across most sports, and his family is jealous of how much time he spends on his precious spreadsheets.

Affiliate Disclosure

ATS.io uses affiliate links. If you sign up through a link on this page, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Rankings are based on hands-on testing and published criteria, and affiliate relationships do not determine placement.